I uploaded two more photos of that same branch, but I don’t know if they will help much. I’ll split them into a separate observation if it is different.
When I found them, I just thought some had fruited and others hadn’t, so I’ll have to look more carefully next time. I don’t know anything about identifying lichen though.
Edit: after reading the descriptions and looking at the observations for both species, I split them into this observation 94634. Most of the ones here were collected off the ground and grouped together, so they are probably mixed. Oops!